Episode 2.4: Student Roundtable - Consensus Reality

How can we acknowledge different knowledge systems in science communication?

Episode Fast Facts

Time: 53 minutes

“Changing positionality changes consensus reality.” 

 

Keelan Powell

 

The Collective: Keelan Powell, Holly Dear, Camila Pardo Uribe, Clare Boon

Two overlapping circles, one with 'Your Experience', one labelled 'My experience'. In the middle is the label, Consensus Reality. A small area next to it in the 'My experience' section is labelled Context Gap - fill with exposition!
Venn diagram of Consensus Reality. CC-BY-SA-4.0 Keelan Powell

Episode Credits

Host: Keelan Powell

Special Guests: Holly Dear and Camila Pardo Uribe

Producers: Keelan Powell, Holly Dear and Camila Pardo Uribe

Audio editor: Keelan Powell

Show notes: Clare Boon

Your reality is like a tree. Each branch is a community whose experiences you share, but as you climb higher, those communities narrow. Your shared experiences become more and more specialised: a ‘special reality’. To get to the outermost branches, you need particular knowledge, skills, or experience. At the bottom of the tree, however, you share a common experience of reality with so many people, you could call it a ‘general reality’. But we sometimes forget it is still part of our great reality tree. Like shared language. Or internet access. That shared reality, the bit we forget is the trunk holding us up? That’s our Consensus Reality. It’s the part we both need to know, and don’t always need to voice, in communication.

In this episode, Master of Science Communication graduate Keelan investigates the concept of Consensus Reality with students Holly and Camila, discussing how this relates to our work as science communicators. They delve into the theory behind the concept, along with the intricacies of mimesis and fiction. The discussion touches on concepts including positionality, the impact of lenses, and the importance of context.

Get your climbing gear ready.

“Take the time to listen, not just speak. You have to trust what others tell you.” – Keelan Powell 
 

Episode links:

Read more about the deficit model here and here and listen to our episode on it here.

Read up on Donna Haraway’s situated knowledge here.

If you’re interested in Bourdieu’s social capital, you can read his original work on it here.

Keywords

Science Communication, Consensus Reality, Positionality

The Collective on this episode:
Keelan Powell

Keelan Powell

Host, Producer and Editor
Camila Pardo Uribe

Camila Pardo Uribe

Producer
Holly Dear

Holly Dear

Producer
Clare Boon

Clare Boon

Research, Governance

We love hearing everyone’s stories of how they got into science communication. What about you? What brought you here? Feel free to share in the comments!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Two white conversation bubbles with a yellow play button in the middle, with the words, "The SciComm Collective" below the logo
Home

Privacy Policy

A black swan against a brushstrokes of yellow and blue
Swan Cultural Learning by Dr Richard Walley

Acknowledgment

We acknowledge, with respect, the Whadjuk people of the Noongar Nation as the Traditional Custodians of the land on which we work and produce The SciComm Collective, and pay our respects to Elders past and present. We extend our respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.

All opinions on this website are representative of individuals and are not representative of The University of Western Australia. The University of Western Australia is not liable for content herein.